"An astronomical correspondence to the 1,470-year cycle of abrupt climate change" - Interactive discussion
http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/4895/2015/cpd-11-4895-2015-discussion.html
"An astronomical correspondence to the 1,470-year cycle of abrupt climate change" - Interactive discussionEC C3100: 'unconvincing author comment', Marie-France Loutre, 29 Jan 2016http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C3100/2016/cpd-11-C3100-2016.pdfEC C3100: 'unconvincing author comment', Marie-France Loutre, 29 Jan 20162016-01-29T18:50:41+01:00AC C2919: 'Response to referees and other comments', Alison Kelsey, 15 Jan 2016http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2919/2016/cpd-11-C2919-2016.pdfAC C2919: 'Response to referees and other comments', Alison Kelsey, 15 Jan 20162016-01-15T12:27:04+01:00SC C2548: '1470-year cycle no longer evident in original archives with improved chronology', Stephen Obrochta, 02 Dec 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2548/2015/cpd-11-C2548-2015.pdfSC C2548: '1470-year cycle no longer evident in original archives with improved chronology', Stephen Obrochta, 02 Dec 20152015-12-02T09:34:07+01:00RC C2542: 'confusing presentation, unclear results', Anonymous Referee #2, 01 Dec 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2542/2015/cpd-11-C2542-2015.pdfRC C2542: 'confusing presentation, unclear results', Anonymous Referee #2, 01 Dec 20152015-12-01T15:17:33+01:00RC C2224: 'Review', Peter Ditlevsen, 05 Nov 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2224/2015/cpd-11-C2224-2015.pdfRC C2224: 'Review', Peter Ditlevsen, 05 Nov 20152015-11-05T13:48:50+01:00AC C2148: 'Further response to Eric Wolff', Alison Kelsey, 30 Oct 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2148/2015/cpd-11-C2148-2015.pdfAC C2148: 'Further response to Eric Wolff', Alison Kelsey, 30 Oct 20152015-10-30T01:26:12+01:00SC C2099: 'Correction', Eric Wolff, 22 Oct 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2099/2015/cpd-11-C2099-2015.pdfSC C2099: 'Correction', Eric Wolff, 22 Oct 20152015-10-22T10:19:59+02:00AC C2098: 'Response to Eric Wolff', Alison Kelsey, 21 Oct 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2098/2015/cpd-11-C2098-2015.pdfAC C2098: 'Response to Eric Wolff', Alison Kelsey, 21 Oct 20152015-10-21T23:52:09+02:00SC C2076: '1470 year cycle is not well-established', Eric Wolff, 21 Oct 2015http://www.clim-past-discuss.net/11/C2076/2015/cpd-11-C2076-2015.pdfSC C2076: '1470 year cycle is not well-established', Eric Wolff, 21 Oct 20152015-10-21T13:30:52+02:00